Buttermilks Farmhouse logo

Buttermilk's Favorites

Order Now
Buttermilk's Own Signature Pancakes

Buttermilk's Own Signature Pancakes

Our full stack, served with your choice of one side.

Add Item
The HOLY Cannoli

The HOLY Cannoli

Cannoli cream stuffed between two slices of our classic French toast.

Add Item
The Flamethrower

The Flamethrower

Spicy sriracha chicken, crumbled bleu cheese and scallions.

Add Item
Chicken & Waffles

Chicken & Waffles

Our Belgian waffle with signature crispy fried chicken and maple drizzle.

Add Item
Shrimp & Grits

Shrimp & Grits

Cajun shrimp over creamy cheese grits with cajun cream sauce.

Add Item

Worth the Short Drive

Worth the Short Drive

Guests come in from across Suffolk County, and both farmhouses sit right on their town's Main Street.

See All Locations

Plan a Group Visit

Plan a Group Visit

Bringing a crowd? Ask about catering or a private event before you make the drive out to see us.

Order Now

Find Buttermilk's Farmhouse

Map of Buttermilks Farmhouse - 93 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY, 11706, US